Big City, Small Robot

TweenbotSeveral years ago, I began to make human-dependent cardboard robots and place them on the streets of New York City. These little robots, which came to be known as Tweenbots (a combination of the words “between” and “robot”), roll at a constant speed, in a straight line, and have a flag that says that they are trying to get to a certain destination (e.g., the southwest corner of Washington Square Park). The flag asks for people to aim the Tweenbot in the right direction to reach its goal.

New York City is a large and bustling place – and if one ascribes to the stereotypes about New Yorkers’ helpfulness, the outlook did not appear promising for these little cardboard robots.

On the other hand, the Tweenbots are irresistibly cute. They have a cheerful posture and move along at a bumbling pace. As you look down at them, the first thing you see is an iconic smiley face made of two large circles for eyes and a line for a mouth.

Scott McCloud, who writes about the theory of cartoons in his book Understanding Comics, explains the deeply embedded mental processes that compel us to interpret everything in our own image; we can’t help but transform two dots and a line into a face. For McCloud, the less realistic –the more abstract and iconic– a character’s features, the more easily we fill in the details based on our own perspective and imagination, “assigning identities and emotions where none exist.” We project ourselves onto characters so that we not only identify with them, we inhabit and become them.

Over the course of a few months, as I observed people interacting with the Tweenbots, I came to realize just how powerful their anthropomorphic and emotive qualities were. At first, I started to perceive this through people’s use of simple gestures that are commonplace in our everyday social interactions; when a pedestrian looked down at a Tweenbot’s smiling face, they couldn’t resist smiling back. This automatic mimicry is a sort of emotional contagion, and goes beyond unconsciously mirroring another’s expression – it also implies that you can “catch” or feel the emotions of another. I saw this automatic response over and over again, and hoped that by smiling in response to the Tweenbots, people were actually feeling happier. I also came to recognize that people were experiencing deeper emotional connections when, moments after they characterized the Tweenbot as happy and non-threatening, they seemed to consider the Tweenbot’s presence in the context of the big city and respond empathetically to their plight.

Empathy is being able to walk a mile in someone’s shoes, to vicariously experience and understand what another is going through. As I watched some people bend down and gently orient the Tweenbot in the right direction, it occurred to me that the Tweenbots were inviting people to extend beyond themselves to experience the city from the perspective of a tiny and tragically cheerful cardboard robot. With their improbable presence on city streets, Tweenbots are the quintessence of vulnerability, of being lost, and of having intention without the means of achieving their goal alone. We all know –or can imagine– what it feels like to be lost or helpless in the face if the city’s massive network of streets, subways and crowds. But this overwhelming milieu may also be the reason that we ignore others who may need help as we go about our daily routines. The unexpected appearance of the Tweenbot, along with their disarming appearance, disrupted the self-focused navigation of the city, inviting people to stop and interact. New York brought the Tweenbots to life when people projected their own feelings onto the simple forms of the Tweenbots, and in a small way for just an instant, they perhaps saw themselves looking up from the sidewalk as a helpless cardboard form.

It seemed entirely possible that this empathetic connection was what motivated so many people to help the Tweenbots. Every time a Tweenbot got stuck in a pothole or started to grind futilely against a curb, someone would come to its rescue. Strangers, who seconds before would have no reason to talk to one another, came together to help. People talked to the Tweenbots, and asked for directions on the Tweenbot’s behalf when they did not know which direction to aim it. Of all the amazing interactions, my favorite was when one man turned a Tweenbot back in the direction it had just come, saying out loud to it “you can’t go that way, it’s toward the road.”

~Kacie Kinzer~

To learn more about the Tweenbots, you can check out the website here.

Tweenbots from kacie kinzer on Vimeo.

5 thoughts on “Big City, Small Robot

  1. Pingback: Big City, Small Robot | On education |

  2. Very interesting. There are many studies that show that when people stand before something vague, abstract and full of gaps, they tend to fill these gaps in the most optimistic way. For example, there is a research by Dan that shows that online dating users who know little about other users would be more interested in them because they fill all the information gaps in their own image . The same principle is here- since the robot’s cartoonish face is really full of gaps (compared with a human/animal face), people tend to “fill in” the gaps of the robots face in the most optimistic way, or in their image. This is why they like the robot so much.

  3. This video brought tears to my eyes. It is good to see SOCIAL sciences folks doing research that plumbs the ways humans are altruistic, caring, helpful, warm, cooperative, and gentle…in the middle of a concrete jungle. It was touching to watch the tender and attentive body language of the people who helped the Tweenbot. It would be very interesting to replicate this study in various big cities, and compare the results.

    When I was in my Ph.D. studies in social sciences in the 1980s, it was all about exploiting people at the mass/demographic level, or manipulating their “hard wiring” to have certain attitudes, buy certain things, vote a certain way, and that was subsumed by the larger goal of careerism. The only other option was to follow the lead of Boomer faculty who were Stickin’ It To The Man by rebelling against…whatever it was they were rebelling against. The larger sense of research as a contemplative discipline by which we might understand ourselves better, and more honestly, simply wasn’t there that I could tell.

    It was, I think, the dark ages. I finished my education, fled my field, and spent my life and skills trying to help Tweenbots (so to speak) at small local levels.

    In the video, nobody did what I would have done: looked around to see if anyone was looking, picked up the Tweenbot, and carried it to its destination. Yes, that would have deprived it of its journey…but I would have first have asked it for sea stories, over coffee. I’m one of the people who can’t look at Mars in the night sky without getting all choked up about the Rover. :)

  4. Pingback: Reality in Game Design | Indie Game Design by Joseph Miller

Share your opinions

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s